Skip to content

Historical field note

This record preserves a closed acceptance-criteria verdict and its supporting verification evidence. It is not a current operating contract; use the numbered book and current runbooks for instructions.

Close-Out: dream finding dreamrepair:965c6e89c762d29f07df25aafd3ac96f (openclaw_fleet_rollout deliverable)

Task: Produce the acceptance-criteria disposition for a low-confidence dream finding scoped to the openclaw_fleet_rollout deliverable for project mac — either apply the smallest appropriate repair / concrete follow-up plan, or, if the finding is not actionable, close it with an explicit reason and the evidence gap. Parent task: "Investigate low-confidence dream finding: mac". Upstream investigation node (ground truth): docs/archive/field-notes/dream-finding-965c6e89.md. Finding: kind failure_pattern, scope project, repo_area mac, fingerprint dreamrepair:965c6e89c762d29f07df25aafd3ac96f, confidence low (score 0.35), backed by exactly one evidence record. Evidence record: mem_4ad6f3bf11fa4534a1569edec925198b (record_type deployment_learning:mac), origin task task_37e658cac7d643aebbed4742a25777a2. Prepared by: fleet worker (verdict node; no production code, test, skill, or deploy edits).

Under the parent acceptance criteria, when the deliverable and its dedicated suite already exist and pass, the finding is not actionable and the correct deliverable is this committed close-out note — not a change to any source module, test, skill, or tool. This verdict adopts and independently re-verifies the ground truth established by the upstream investigation (docs/archive/field-notes/dream-finding-965c6e89.md): the finding is a low-confidence, single-record failure_pattern derived from a deployment_learning recap of an implementation-audit task, not a reproducible current defect. It mirrors the NOT ACTIONABLE close-out reached for the near-duplicate finding dreamrepair:3dc2cf... (docs/archive/field-notes/closeout-dreamrepair-3dc2cf-openclaw-fleet-rollout.md).

No files under src/mac/, tests/, skills/, or deploy/ were modified.

Corroboration in the task worktree

The openclaw_fleet_rollout deliverable and its suite were re-verified here against the bootstrapped .venv, reproducing the investigation's result:

  • Deliverable present and intact — src/mac/openclaw_fleet_rollout.py (209 lines) exposes every required public symbol: ROLLOUT_PLAN_SCHEMA = "mac.openclaw_fleet_rollout.v1" (src/mac/openclaw_fleet_rollout.py:22), RolloutPlanStep (src/mac/openclaw_fleet_rollout.py:31), RolloutPlan (src/mac/openclaw_fleet_rollout.py:41), RolloutResult (src/mac/openclaw_fleet_rollout.py:65), build_staged_rollout_plan (src/mac/openclaw_fleet_rollout.py:83), and execute_staged_rollout (src/mac/openclaw_fleet_rollout.py:139).
  • Test suite green via the canonical hermetic runner: scripts/run-contract-tests.sh tests/test_openclaw_fleet_rollout.py -q → 52 passed (exit 0). The suite (tests/test_openclaw_fleet_rollout.py:1, 545 lines) covers builder validation, canary/promote staging, the executor simulate/deploy/health paths, and a module-contract regression guard.

There is no failing test, assertion, trace, or reproducer to repair.

Why the finding is not a live defect (evidence gap)

  • Single, non-reproducing record. The only supporting evidence (mem_4ad6f3bf11fa4534a1569edec925198b, deployment_learning:mac) is a historical deployment/learning recap from an implementation-audit task (task_37e658cac7d643aebbed4742a25777a2). It carries no failing assertion, stack trace, current reproduction, or named offending code path, and the record id does not appear anywhere in the checked-out repository.
  • No independent corroboration. Nothing in the checked-out repository — neither the module, the 52-test suite, nor the hermetic runner — reproduces a rollout failure.
  • Score is a structural floor, not a severity signal. The 0.35 confidence is the classifier's deterministic single-record floor (CONFIDENCE_THRESHOLDS["low"] = ("low", 0.35), src/mac/dream_cycle_classifier.py:87), returned by _confidence_for(...) (src/mac/dream_cycle_classifier.py:233) at its final fall-through (src/mac/dream_cycle_classifier.py:258) whenever evidence_count < 2 and the candidate is not high/medium. Low confidence here reflects evidence volume (one record), not a confirmed defect.

Follow-up recommendation

  • Close the finding as NOT ACTIONABLE. No source, skill, or tool change is warranted; the deliverable and its tests are intact and green.
  • No new test/guard is added. The module-contract regression guard already present in tests/test_openclaw_fleet_rollout.py is the appropriate standing guard for this deliverable; adding another would be redundant.
  • Systemic note (no code change): single-record deployment_learning recaps of implementation/audit tasks structurally surface at the 0.35 floor and should be triaged as historical learning artifacts rather than live defects unless a second, independent reproducing record is attached. This mirrors the systemic observation recorded for the near-duplicate 3dc2cf close-out and is a triage observation, not a classifier change.