Skip to content

Historical field note

This record preserves prior investigation or planning evidence. It is not a current operating contract; use the numbered book and current runbooks for instructions.

Close-Out: dream finding dreamrepair:3dc2cf317ea21e032952a355c3550f88 (openclaw_fleet_rollout deliverable)

Task: Produce the acceptance-criteria review verdict for a low-confidence dream finding scoped to the openclaw_fleet_rollout deliverable for project mac — either apply the smallest appropriate repair / concrete follow-up plan, or, if the finding is not actionable, close it with an explicit reason and the evidence gap. Parent task: task_5287b80a718c432ca0e78807ccf45911 (goal: "Investigate low-confidence dream finding: mac"). Upstream investigation node: docs/archive/field-notes/dream-finding-3dc2cf.md. Finding: kind failure_pattern, scope project, repo_area mac, fingerprint dreamrepair:3dc2cf317ea21e032952a355c3550f88, confidence low (score 0.35), backed by exactly one evidence record. Origin task of the one evidence record: task_663c141c19494c76b0a0d28caa8fa07a. Evidence record: mem_a718733f11c040e98ae608ad93307df6 (record_type deployment_learning:mac). Prepared by: fleet worker (verdict node; no production code or test edits). Assessment date: 2026-07-16

Under the parent acceptance criteria, when the deliverable and its tests already exist and pass, the finding is not actionable and the correct deliverable is this committed close-out note — not a change to any source module, test, skill, or tool. This verdict adopts and independently re-verifies the ground truth established by the upstream investigation (docs/archive/field-notes/dream-finding-3dc2cf.md): the finding is a low-confidence, single-record failure_pattern derived from a deployment_learning recap of the original implementation task, not a reproducible current defect.

No files under src/mac/, tests/, skills/, or deploy/ were modified.

Corroboration in the task worktree

The openclaw_fleet_rollout deliverable and its suite were re-verified here against the bootstrapped .venv, reproducing the investigation's result:

  • Deliverable present and intact — src/mac/openclaw_fleet_rollout.py (209 lines) exposes every required public symbol: ROLLOUT_PLAN_SCHEMA = "mac.openclaw_fleet_rollout.v1" (src/mac/openclaw_fleet_rollout.py:22), RolloutPlanStep (src/mac/openclaw_fleet_rollout.py:31), RolloutPlan (src/mac/openclaw_fleet_rollout.py:41), RolloutResult (src/mac/openclaw_fleet_rollout.py:65), build_staged_rollout_plan (src/mac/openclaw_fleet_rollout.py:83), and execute_staged_rollout (src/mac/openclaw_fleet_rollout.py:139).
  • Test suite green via the canonical hermetic runner: scripts/run-contract-tests.sh tests/test_openclaw_fleet_rollout.py -q → 52 passed (exit 0). The suite (tests/test_openclaw_fleet_rollout.py:1, 545 lines) covers builder validation, canary/promote staging, the executor simulate/deploy/health paths, and a module-contract regression guard.

There is no failing test, assertion, trace, or reproducer to repair.

Why the finding is not a live defect (evidence gap)

  • Single, non-reproducing record. The only supporting evidence (mem_a718733f11c040e98ae608ad93307df6, deployment_learning:mac) is a historical build/repair learning recap from the original implementation task (task_663c141c19494c76b0a0d28caa8fa07a). It carries no failing assertion, stack trace, current reproduction, or named offending code path.
  • No independent corroboration. Nothing in the checked-out repository — neither the module, the 52-test suite, nor the hermetic runner — reproduces a rollout failure.
  • Score is a structural floor, not a severity signal. The 0.35 confidence is the classifier's deterministic single-record floor (CONFIDENCE_THRESHOLDS["low"] = ("low", 0.35), src/mac/dream_cycle_classifier.py:87), returned by _confidence_for(...) whenever evidence_count < 2 and the candidate is not high/medium (src/mac/dream_cycle_classifier.py:233). Low confidence here reflects evidence volume (one record), not a confirmed defect.

Follow-up recommendation

  • Close the finding as NOT ACTIONABLE. No source, skill, or tool change is warranted; the deliverable and its tests are intact and green.
  • No new test/guard is added. The module-contract regression guard already present (tests/test_openclaw_fleet_rollout.py) is the appropriate standing guard for this deliverable; adding another would be redundant.
  • Systemic note (no code change): single-record deployment_learning recaps of original implementation tasks structurally surface at the 0.35 floor and should be triaged as historical learning artifacts rather than live defects unless a second, independent reproducing record is attached. This is a triage observation, not a defect requiring a classifier change.